you'd enjoy it more than you think you would

...as my fantasies generally have a single penis rule - my own.  Sounds like your uncomfortable with the idea too.  If it's outside your comfort zone I'd say don't do it.  Everyone has boundaries, you respect hers, she'll respect yours as well.

Not Your Normal 3-way?

I love having two guys at one time. But the comfort level has to be just right. I dont think its not normal just different. You cant knock it until you try it!

Amsterdam

If DP is all she is looking for...

If the most important thing for your gal is to experience double penetration and you are still uncomfortable with another guy, you have two alternatives: 1) bring another girl with a strap-on, 2) get a menage-a-trois for two harness.  Iv'e used it and it's AWESOME!!!  The link below shows will give you an idea of what it looks lie, but there is a better, much more comfortable one at the Hustler store on Sunset.

I did a MFM 3some a few years back and it was awesome.

It was not planned, it sort of just happened.

Before I did it, I never would have thought that I would be into that kind of play, but i was great.

There was no contact between the men, and the only DP was one in the pink and one in the mouth, however I would do it again in a heartbeat

I did a few stints at a local Swing Club and hooked up with a couple a few times. She was hot and her husband was rather passive so she and I would go at it until she climbed on for some cowgirl...then hubby joined in for some D.P. action. It was hot because she really got off on it.

After a couple of visits she arragned a 4 way with another single guy, me and the hubby....needles to say she way in heaven with all the attention.

I came close to another session recently when a provider friend asked me if I wanted to join her and another client....I said "Why Not"....but he backed out before I arrived. Heck you only go around once right....If a hot naked woman wants to give something a try who am I to say no.

In my single days, I used to be quite a bit more adventurous.  Can't believe I didn't catch anything on way either.  Anyway... I had a friend with benefits and she and I tried a number of things.  Including a few times with a male friend of mine.  Like an earlier post was talking about, she had wanted to try a DP... and who was I to say no!    It was a lot of fun, but you definitely need to be comfortable with yourself, and all the players involved for it to be truly enjoyable.  Otherwise, you'll spend your time thinking rather than experiencing.

sounds like gym class

i really think other guys are gross, can't understand why women like anyone but me.

I have done this and stuff like it and as long as there is no desire or intention of intentional touching between the guys, just go for it. You can warm up with her doing oral on one guy while the other hits it doggie. Before you try it, study a few "educational" videos on the web paying close attention to positions and size relationships when they get to the DP part; it is harder than it looks, at least it was for me the two times that I achieved DP - each time it only held together for a few minutes. lol

I would love to do that, and I'll let you choose if you want to do her in the pink or the balloon knot!   Or switch!  This sounds like a great time!

Had the experience once with a non-pro girl who was, and still is, a very close friend. We were both married to other people at the time, and had been having an affair for several months. A few too many drinks at a bar took us back to the other guy's place who was a friendly acquaintance of mine. Next thing you know, she's sending unmistakable signals that she wants us both. I too am 1 of those guys who wants to be the only penis in the room, and spent most of the time contorting myself into whatever position I could to avoid body contact with the other guy. One saving grace was that mine was substantially bigger than his, and I kinda felt bad for him at one point when I'd left the room for a break and something to drink. He walked into the kitchen with a real downcast look and said 'she told me she wants you---you're the one with the meat'. Better me than him, I guess. Anyway, afterward I could tell that she was very ashamed and embarrassed about the whole alcohol fueled incident, and over the next several days I had to talk to her repeatedly to get her to realize she shouldn't hang her head and beat herself up. She and I rarely discuss the incident, but fortunately are still able to laugh about it a bit. It's a high wire act to be sure. Be careful.