I know that's a weasely answer but either the makeup works or it doesn't.  I've seen women who look like everything from a classic bombshell to a sexy perfume ad to a Halloween costume gone bad due to makeup. I guess the most I can say is if you're using the makeup to enhance and highlight that'll work; if you're using it to disguise or feign then not so much.

I prefer no make up no perfume.  I have always liked the natural look.  I request this on most of my dates.  A lot of ladies are uncomfortable with this they tell me they feel naked with out it. Or that it hides some small imperfections.  My very first Bj in HS was with a girl with acne, I thought it was kind of a turn on.  To each his own.  All the ladies I have seen are beautiful regardless.

Gimme them "smokey" eyes and red lips.

Sorry it's a bitch to remove.

I don't care if there are acne scars, pimples, crows feet, or whatever else someone might be trying to cover, I'll take that over a thick layer of makeup any day. But despite my requests, it seems like the girls don't take me seriously and layer it on anyway. I also prefer un-enhanced ta-tas, so maybe I'm a purist. (Grooming style is at the her discretion, I'm happy either way)

little makeup and no perfume. I may want to have a shower with her before and after so her makeup may run.

Natural is best...

I recently saw Jessa Sweets and specifically asked her to wear no makeup and no clothes and that's how she greeted me and it was wonderful!