You gave him an opportunity to speak up. In fact you gave him 2 chances. His reply was cryptic and mis-leading to say the least. I believe there are guys out there that do manufacture fake reviews just to keep or get VIP status. I noticed a guy last week that claims he was in Phoenix on business and saw a provider that is in Pasadena, and I know for a fact she does not travel. If we can't be honest with each other here, how much trust can a provider or a client have. We depend on each other for discretion and safety.

to be unwilling to giving you the information you needed. I can't see why he'd be unwilling to give you the email address he had supposedly used in the first place, and I don't see where you did anything wrong.

You most definitely did the right thing.  While I don't write many review, I have always sent a copy to the provider before I have posted it.  And I never write bad reviews.  Maybe she was having a bad day or something.

But to have a made up review posted, good or bad, is just wrong.  

Just my 2 cents.

Did you ever consider the John may have seen you from another board and did not want to reveal his ID from that board thus associating both identities? I used to have an identity on local boards in other states that was completely separate from my TER ID or the other nation boards. Only a few trusted girls know/knew more than one ID. Why because some boards are run by locals who will remove negative yet truthful reviews for some providers in exchange for free service or other such things.

I see his response as not cryptic but safeguarding his ass. After all, this entire site is about fictitious encounters. And he was maybe posting because in his “dream” he did have a great time and thought it worthy of a review reflecting that. I would have also responded the same way by telling you it is not my loss. Why, because my membership is paid for and we know that a decent review is worth money to providers, so yeah not my loss either if I were him. His and my ultimate goal might be to safeguard our multiple hobby identities.

You have quite few reviews and all of them seem to great. Everyone gets once in a while a less than stellar review. Sometimes there just isn't chemistry regardless of how the previous reviewers have felt. It also depends on the reviewer I for once am very conservative about giving 9's and 10's not because the providers aren't hot or don't perform well it's just because they aren't my 9's and 10's.
When reading the reviews I give very little credibility for reviews where the reviewer only gives out 9's and 10's. I usually look more at the average rating as well as the actual descriptions to see if the provider sounds like something I might like.
I would also get offended if someone would call one of my reviews fake and would'n definitely want to give out my email or phone number. I would have however told you were we met so that you would know that I have actually met you.

IMHO some people like to be anonymous  ,i sometimes wait a long time to write a review simply because i  figure the girl will forget who i was especially if it's  not  a great review.

the review being fake! A lot of guys write fake reviews so the can get VIP. Exposing the BS is what makes it so important! You rock girl!

I don't think you did anything wrong....but

But it sure seems like you spent a lot of time and energy on something that is really of no consequence.  We've never met [ something I would hope to correct btw] but I've watched the LA board long enough as well as checked out your reviews and even observed the miraculous evolution of your upper body adornments to recognize you are a well loved...well respected lady who needs not worry too much about the actions of a singular fruit cake.  Unfortunately a lot of jerks submit fake reviews for free membership.  It sucks but fergedabodit......oh yeah....one more thing....love the new look !!