Have you ever had someone say or do something that made you go, "hmmmmmmmm.. "

Recently I met someone. He was nice. Everything was fun. After we finished up the sexy time he asked if he could play a song on his laptop that he wanted to hear.
I said, sure ...why not?
He says that he loves this song. It's all piano.
He asks if I know where the song is from.
I say, Hmm.. I don't think so.
He says, so quickly and with such seriousness, "it's the opening theme song to American Psycho."

My. Jaw. Just. Went. Duh?