Poker Gent's great survey reminds me of a study years ago, I think it was the Mich. U. psych dept.  They took 100 album pics of guys and asked 100 campus girls to rate the top 10 guys by looks.  Then they asked 100 campus guys to list the top 10 guys who would appeal most to girls.  It was terrible, guys. We just seem to have no idea of what kind of guy appeals to girls. I think Brad Pitt and Cary Grant would appeal to them.
  Then the psychs showed the guys 100 random album pics of girls and asked them to rate by looks.  The girls then picked out whom they thought would appeal most to the guys.  The girls came out about 33% better at rating girls who appeal to guys.  Its ok with me, because Im really not into guys,  I will stick with girls.