Is time a factor?
Does she need to put in years, or can she be so good that it can be done on one tour?
A 90 day wonder or one wild year and done?

Valid point badger, legend vs ATF.  My point of view of a legend is someone who has been in the game for a long while and has a “exceeds expectations” reputation on a consistent bases as far as looks, service, body, and attitude.  A provider who is well known and discussed on many different occasions. As far as LA legends are concerned , most of us know who they are:
Stella, Rebecca, Cari, Megan(retired), to name a few. They all have a long list of reviews on file and they all maintained an above avg rating of 9.  In my opinion Sia meets that criteria. But I could live with her being my ATF list if there are mongers who disagree .  

universal popularity with guys who have different tastes.   This shows she knows how to size up customers quickly and play to their individual needs and desires.  The result of this is the second phase, where they have so many regulars they are often hard to book, which sustains their status as legends.  It goes without saying that to achieve this, it requires excellent skills, better than average looks, and a bigger than life personality.  

I can only add that the changes in the visa requirements regarding Korea have added to this situation. We now have the “90 day wonders” where the gals come and go very quickly, not remaining here long enough to be able to look down the line. I wonder if any of the “really hot” gals of today will ever become legends.

A legend IMHO is the complete package: ageless beauty, sustainability, reputation, respect, independent, exclusivity and consistency.  

Thanks for the participation.

I feel the same about a couple of favorites and because the criteria is subjective, other Mongers will disagree.
But some will feel the same as me, I've been sent PM's about the Kgirl or review, wondering why other guys haven't picked up on her all-around skills, looks and attitude!
But it will always go back to, "It's all subjective"!

longevity , reputation ,peer  respect . In each field and arena you have your folk heroes, icons and legends including the small insignificant world of Angeleno k-dolls. Yes initially and individually it is subjective but  ultimately it is collective recognition. Within the K-girl hobbiest  community you others who stand the test of time  will be considered legends within this era."

Badger

And I feel like it doesnt change the criteria stated by people in this thread.

legendary status is being able to retain a following of loyal regulars.  BBFS does not lend itself to the retention of customers for months or years.  The nature of BBFS mongers is to try as many different BBFS girls as they can rather than find one they like and stick with her. This is why almost all BBFS girls tour.  Once all of the BB hounds have seen them, there is no reason to repeat, business slows down for the girl, so she tours to the next town, where the same thing will happen all over again.  Of course, there are a few outliers, so no need to tell me, "I know a girl . . . ." because I'm sure you do, but the overwhelming evidence from customer patterns is that BBFS customers are historically not inclined to see the same BBFS girl over and over for an extended period of time like the GFE customers do.  

I do not see any correlation between girls touring and bbfs, as I also don't see any correlation between legends and whether or not they use cover, at least here in the bay.

just not her name.
If you check the BB thread on a different site you'll see there are plenty of guys repeating and keeping the Kgirls business going.

her career in LA.  She started in Philly for several years, then did a couple of years in Seattle, and came to LA after the LOEG bust shut down the business there.  Pepsi may be a legend to some, but more due to infamy in pushing the envelope on BBFS than anything else.  Allie has a good shot at becoming a legend, but not even three years in the biz yet, so let's see what kind of staying power she has.  Phoebe has just recently crossed 100 reviews in just over a year.  BBFS girls rack up reviews more quickly than GFE girls, because they have few regulars taking the available time slots, as I mentioned in another post recently.  That's a good start, but if she left tomorrow, she would be forgotten fairly quickly because the vast majority of BBFS customers are one and done and on to the next new BBFS girl.  A monger once posted here about BBFS girls, "See them the first week they are here and don't go back, and you will greatly lessen your odds of catching an STD, because the more different contacts they have, the odds of getting an STD will catch with them."  

First, just because you don't like bbfs doesnt make bbfs girls not legends.

Also, I said before BBFS Kgirls will use a cover if you want it.
They are versatile^^!

outliers and gave Megan as an example.  I didn't say she was the only one.  I'm saying that in most cases, we don't know who the current BBFS girls are that will be considered legends someday.  You understand that a "legend" is someone who is still talked about with reverence AFTER they retire, right?   All you can call them now is top-tier girls.  Since openly advertised BBFS is relatively new, not many of those girls have retired yet.  Can you name another one that has retired at least 3 years ago that also retains the legend status of Megan?  (BTW, the three 2022 reviews of Megan are fake.  She has not worked since 2019 according to her former booker. )    

To blow up the discussion a little more^^!

Current greats are generally called things like MVP, Stars and, well, Great.

For me, legends are ones who are still discussed and reminasced frequently.  Likes of Lohan, Love Kim, Megan, etc who have retired for many years by now are still mentioned by many dudes.  I wasn't a huge fan of those girls however many guys found them to be desired for various reasons.    

I would consider a kgirl with10+ years of experience, 250+ reviews and consistently high ratings in the mid 8’s to be worthy of K-Legend Hall of Fame induction!  These are the superstars I “grew up with” in my hobby life!  I have all of these 10+ year superstars in my rotation; Amber, Asia, Lyn, Min and Stella! It would be tough to rank them 1-5, as I have seen them over so many years and all have been great over time!   The amazing thing is that many newer hobbyists are still ranking them consistently high! Of course while the level of their services remains high, their looks may have slipped a notch! Even if one of these legends are only getting low to mid 8’s today, I still consider them to be legends!  Bottom line - we are all lucky to enjoy their longevity, sexual prowess, experience and beauty!

...and to be referred to as such by the sports media.  You want me to name an NBA player who is still playing that is referred to as a "legend" by the sports media?    OK, how about LeBron James?

Best Post of the Year, when BigP denied stalking me on the LA Board.  

This is incorrect. Legendary status doesn't have to be someone who isn't current. Someone already posted links to current players and coaches being legendary. A certain coach is still coaching, over 25 years and is called legendary.

"I can't admit I was wrong, not even with my weaselly 'I stand corrected'.  All can do is deflect, distract and divert with a post from my personal White Knight who comes to my rescue on every board."

of Kgirls who have been in the biz 20 years and are still in it.    Who are your examples?  

The point I was making is that there are legends in the p4p biz that have been there for ages and are in fact, legends. You don't have to retire to be called a legend. You don't have to work for 15 years either. It's just some dumb arbitrary constraints you put on, just like with excluding bbfs girls.

Most are in their 40's, some in their 50's and all having started young in Korea before aging out? 40ish - 20ish = 20ish. It's the old math.

I didn't say it couldn't happen, I just asked for some names.  So far,  . . . . . crickets.    I will also guarantee you that AMP Viet grannies (plenty of those in Garden Grove/Stanton area)  who never worked in a K-org are NOT legends in the same way Kgirl legends are remembered.  You were around then, so you know the kinds of girls that became legends.  I'm betting you saw your fair share of them.

I named some names. It's not my fault you didn't read them or pretended to not read them.

It's ambiguous at best and just because you throw out your ground rules doesn't mean everyone or even most everyone agrees.

now you are walking it back to 15 years.   I believe Pepsi has finally retired from providing, so she is indeed a legend.  Ceroni retired for a few years and then came back.  If BA guys say she is legend, I will accept that.  Sera has been around 12 years, not 15, but when she retires, I may refer to her as a legend.  It depends on whether she stays too long in the game and starts getting burned out and bad reviews, because that is how she would be remembered.  

I never put any arbitrary constraints. I said a girl can be in the game for anywhere from one to 20 years and they can be a legend. You are the one who clung to that number like it means something.

If a girl is a unicorn or her impact was profound that many mongers always remember her, I think a year is fine too. Youre welcome to disagree.

in my original post, does time come into play.
One of the Kgirls I was thinking about when I started the thread was here for about 11 months.
She is always looked at as a legend/unicorn with a lot of mongers and she actually just started her second tour in L.A.
She might not have to be in the game for 5, 10 or 20 years, because she will probably get to her goal before that time.
Also, I don't know what her goal is or if she has one.

I think it's a rather fluid question. For example, it would be hard to claim someone like Jimi Hendrix or Elvis Presley were not, and perhaps still are, legends. How about James Dean? Or we could go farther back, Samson from the Bible? You don't hear much about them -- and I suspect for some people you'd just get a "Huh, who?!" response. Does that mean they are or are not legends? Is legend status a perishable/transient state? Maybe.

A girl, her service, her attitude, her looks, etc is a tangible and real memory.

touring in the BA.  Not being able to maintain a tight schedule right here in LA militates AGAINST her being a legend.  Legends don't usually have to tour to stay busy.  I may have to revise my opinion of her being a legend.  Lol

I'm sure people who consider her a legend will reconsider once poster coeur de lion on TER reconsiders. Kol

a review of Pepsi in my review history.  If I had seen her SINCE I started reviewing here, I would have reviewed her here.  Last time I saw her was BEFORE 2015.  I believe I already posted that she is a legend primarily for bringing BBFS out into the open, not because her overall service was anything to write home about, although she paid the price for being an industry leader with numerous LE busts.  

Your "Pepsi retiring" gaffe.  Get it now? Not your Pepsi. It was your gaffe about her retiring.

in December that she was going to retire.  That was also the month of her LAST review.  Her profile does not list her as serving any other city than LA.  There are no new reviews AFTER her December reviews from LA that are from any city in the BA.  How is that possible if she has been working there?  I think the "gaffe" might be mistaking a monger someone for Pepsi who might have hijacked her photos to use in their ad.  This happens a lot.  A girl retires and a new girl starts using their photos.  Regardless, if there is no trail to find her after she last worked in LA, why is it a gaffe for anyone to not know she is working in the BA when she is getting no reviews?  I wish I was psychic like you, but I rely on evidence to make conclusions.  

Or you just picked up some hearsay you give me so much shit about?

I see they finally removed her from lineup after I posted... but I thought of that

are NOT a big fucking secret.  You can't write a review without providing one, and you don't need to be VIP to access the link on a profile.  You have proven her PHOTOS were there.  I'm still waiting for a review or two to prove SHE was there.  A Kgirl like Pepsi should get at least one review the first week she works.  Most FOB girls get at least one review the first week, so are you sure she was there, or were here photos just being used for B & S by the org?  Orgs know that about a third of guys will be switchable to a different girl when they text of call, so it's not uncommon to use photos of girls who are not there for this purpose.  Lack of reviews is one way to spot a B & S scheme, especially when it's in another city.  

As I thought, she told someone else and you used that info. Lol. But of course your hearsay is different from other people's houses arsay. Of course.  

Why haven't you reviewed her?  

I saw her first tour, pretty sure I told you and badger that in another thread.
And I told you then why I didn't write a review. Because the link was gone after she bounced, just like this time.  

http://www.theeroticreview.com/reviews/pepsi-6506450749-306531

so this is my last exchange on this topic.  When you have to lie, it means you know you are losing the argument.  I put up the post on the link below FIVE days ago, which is further up this thread.  

Very valid point and perhaps true because most of the guys that BBFS a girl and CIP a girl and after 2nd or 3rd sessions, there is no further interest. But you will be surprised on how some of these BBFS girls are hoping to find husband or BF from the mongers.

Curious where you got your 'Most' of BBFS guys info from.