Can't speak for Miami, but Scarlett's in Tampa is like a hidden secret among the guys I know.  You catch the right gal, and the private cubicles really are hot.  

I've been to Scarlett's in West Palm Beach. Nice place, pretty girls, steakhouse part of the business.

Have  never been to Scarletts.   Tootsies is quite impressive.   Heard some good thigns about Scarletts'   Suggest you try both and give us a followup

Tootsies is still a seedy strip club. Depends what you are looking for. Scarlett's entertainment and talent is far superior.  
That being said, they just got bought by Rick's Cabaret so let's see what direction it takes them.

Good luck

Kisses
The Sexy Swinger Elle

Scarletts has always been one of the most expensive clubs. Really pretty girls.
Tootsies also gets some lookers, and is still a little high price-wise for South Florida, but you can find a gem hear and there for a better price than Scarletts.
Much better "bang for your buck" in Pompano clubs. LOL Many Cuban girls in the South Florida clubs, but Pompano is somewhat over-run with them.

Just my $.02.