To me, that's why you have to read the reviews.  The numbers don't tell you the whole story.  Even then, there are some reviews that I don't trust because they are short on the details I'm looking for -- how enthusiastic a provider is, what kind of likes/dislikes they have, how much they match their pictures, how far away their incall is from where I am.

I think You should look.....

at all the reviews as a whole...if there is only one out of how many...chances are it was him...I had someone write a review on me...and he wrote how nervous he was...and he was shy...and he wanted to take it slow and to top it off he was a clock watcher...lol..a new one on me...anyway..when he wrote the review he based it on him and Not me...so needless to say it was a good review...however Not Great...when You read his....it's Not in line with all the other reviews...I personally would take into consideration of the majority....just my 2 cents  Great question though...

is to check his other reviews to see if there is a pattern of him being overly critical. I've read some guys' reviews who just seem impossible to please. Some people would complain if you hung them with a new rope. If that's the case, I would just ignore his review, especially if the lady gets good reviews consistently.

If he says she was "standoffish," you can figure he had halitosis.

So on and so forth.