Cityvibe kind of had a little run a number of years ago when CL was shut down, but they dropped off. I've never even looked at the other one.

Some of these sites are better depending on what part of the country you're visiting. When I was traveling several years ago, I learned this by trial and error.

Cityvibe is close to useless and myproviderguide is little more than a platform for spammy adult dating sites. I have a hard time believing anyone finds anything good on either site. Just my 2 cents.