do you prefer clean shaven, nicely trimmed or all natural on a guy down below???

I vote for trimmed

Shaving itches something fierce when it grows back so you might want to pass on that option.

I agree with Olivia! Shaven can end up itching, but long hairs get in the way, and might shed sometimes...
Another point I'd like to make is that a razor can make for nasty cuts. And we all want to stay safe... so cuts "down there" are not a good idea for you or for us...