I have read some reviews of gentlemen that have reviewed girls but their experience was horrible and way  below the norm for the girl. Let me explain. Joe Blow reviews a girl that has an average of 8.5 performance 9 looks and he gives her a 6/5. Is he a dirt bag or a true to form? I am losing confidence, sorry to say in the integrity of some reviews I read. I mean did he shit on this girl with an 8.5 average because he was dirty or a heavy smoker, drunk, shit stain skivies that skeaved her or did he not wash up or not shower? Chime in because I am seeing someone for the 10th time who is rock solid 9 and a particular reviewer who has an average rating of the girls he has scene, 19 to be exact, gave her a 6/5. keep in mind she has 60 rev's and again her average is a 9/9 so go figure.

doc

If the highest score he gives is a 7, while others give her 8-10, then just adjust the curve.

More important than the numbers is what he says.

If he is always disatisfied about something, then it's more him, not her.

Your scenario could be right. Could just be he's a harsh critic, too.  And could be both.

I've also noticed the opposite situation where a provider has many poor reviews and then one recent review from a "new" member that absolutely raves about her.  btw These are the same ones that often say "treat her with respect and you will be truly rewarded."  
Not saying we shouldn't treat others with respect of course.   But this comment, frequently from a new member, frequently when a provider does not have many favorable reviews, gives me cause to pause.

The review process is not perfect, but it sure helps me out.  I'd take my changes with 60 reviews with mostly 9's and one review with a 6/5.  Certainly more than a provider with 3 reviews, 2 poor and 1 fantastic one from a new member.

If you and I are thinking about the same guy, then you might find that his reviews are not quite as negative as the grades he gives.  If one guy, especially someone with several reviews already, is uniformly sub-par, then I chalk it up to that guy's idiosyncratic standards -- or maybe he's just a grump.  You can't judge solely by the numbers (you can tell I'm not into sabermetrics).  In fact, if a girl with 9/9s across the board has one sub-par review, I tend to ignore it.  The girls I tend to stay away from are those whose reviews fluctuate wildly from 10s to 6s -- with my luck, I'll catch her on one of those bad days.  Too bad the providers don't write reviews about us -- or is it?

Posted by theolperfesser, 1/19/2011 5:51:19 AM

Too bad the providers don't write reviews about us -- or is it?

Well, perhaps they do.  

I'm new to this site, and the hobby in general, but have put up 2 reviews recently out of the three girls I've seen.  One review was actually not approved with the reason being that I was new and the girl had no other reviews.  I emailed TER and basically said if they had doubts about it email me and I'll give them my phone number.  As of last night, it got approved, but I get where they're coming from trying to screen fake reviews, especially if they are hyping a new girl.

As for subpar reviews, I think the rules themselves may have a lot to do with this.  

"In order to keep our performance ratings consistent, we set up the following system: An escort provider is only eligible to earn up to a 7, unless she is willing to perform one or some of the following during a session: Kisses With Tongue, Bare-Back Blow Job, Really Bi, and Anal Sex. For each of these services that are offered, her potential max score is raised by one point, with 10 as an absolute maximum.

This does not mean she earns extra points for offering the service(s); just that she is now eligible for a higher score. Her maximum eligible score is based on what is offered, not what is performed during your session with her. You may or may not be interested in the “extra” services she offers, but the fact she offers them makes her eligible for the higher score."

On my first review, I gave the provider a 6, but I was giving her a 6 out of a maximum 7.  I had fun with the girl and would see her again, and I gave a very detailed write-up of the meeting, but if 7 is the absolute maximum without any gfe or extras, then 6 was the right score for her.  

If people are actually following these rules, then there probably shouldn't be that many 9s out there.  Just my 2 cents.

There is a site call the Black list where the providers can go and voice their thoughts
I think it is only about negative information though