Pepe's pizza is over rated in my book.
Have tried it at the original, which it was the best and at two of their chain stores, not as good.
Santarpio's is ok, old school, Italian pizza. It is messy though.
Ciao in Chelsea is very good, cooked in a wood fired brick oven, great dough, that is crispy outside, light fluffy inside
fresh ingredients. This is my go to place.
Regina's is ok, also old school Italian, nothing special
There are so many local pizza places in every city and town. I am sure there are many hidden gems
Also it depends on what style and how you like you pizza.
There are many good Greek pizza's also, have had some really good one's. Do not remember any names lol
I would be happy to deliver a pizza of your choice for you to enjoy, Adeline, hit me up with a message here!