Durex "Performax" gets the #1 rating for reliability, with Lifestyles and Trojan following close behind, though their testing methodology was rather boring, to say the least.  (Inflate them with air until they burst.)  

Now if they included "pleasurable sensation" in their rating criteria, and included some videos of their testing methods, they might succeed in expanding their readership base.

(The worst rating for reliability was for Night Light brand "Glow in the Dark" condoms.  No comment...)