Since we're talking about ladies born in 1934 and 1938 respectively, which is older than my current tastes, I assume you mean the characters "in their primes".

Ginger took all those clothes and make-up for a "3 hour tour".  That's a bit High Maintenance and borders on Narcissism. 5'9" and 38's aside... She'd likely say 'oh, you messed up my make-up!' That would detract from the experience.

Mary Ann, OTOH, was Girl Next Door is size and shape (5'4", 34-23-34) so my imagination says she's much more likely to be GFE. Besides, demure in public is often explosive in bed.

Those statements aside: If you look at a scrapbook of Tina Louise and Dawn Wells, I'd kick neither to the curb... back in their day.

ga_kosh, who says the Professor should have spent some QT with both ladies.

Also, I've always had a weakness for that country girl look.

scrumptious little brunettes have always been at the top of my list when playing on the otherside of the fence.

It's a small island, why choose?

Threesome!

I would have to......

have them both! They are friends right? I dont think they would mind a little 3some action. I wouldnt choose lol I would just take them both. If Ginger bitched about her make up, I would just pull out my blindfold and my strap on! Mary Ann would probably get off on that.
Hugs and kisses
TL

Total nerd right, but once trained he probably had the staying power of the energizer dildo.  I would normally guess maryanne, but she always seemed to moon after the professor and looked at Gilligan like a little brother.  I figure ginger would play for the money, mr Howell, and would only look at gilligan if she needed something, hmmmmm provider in training?  So poor gilligan got milfed by you guessed it, lovey, nearest thing to a cabana boy after all.

Although I always figured Skipper to be from the British navy, so it is most likely the little buddy was buggered regularly in the hammock, losing his tail cherry that way.

Thanks Cara for the pictures for reference! After meticulous study, I choose Ginger. I want the hot Maureen O'Hara type redhead. She may cost more and require a bit more maintenance but she's worth every penny! I'd love to pull that curled red hair while it was between my legs. Yum! Ginger just doesn't do it for me? But then again, I've never been too much into the girl next door type, LOL unless I live next door the the playboy mansion...

she's got dick sucking lips, nice  tits and that great ass/hips plus those long legs to warp around you.  would love the get her from behind !!

(edited by mod to add eom to subject line only message. DD)

-- Modified on 9/19/2011 12:24:05 PM

Its always the girl next door for me, its why I watch so much amateur porn!