but take this into consideration...

he met me (for the first time) for an "intro" (aka quicky). When he called, I was in the pool and he was only a few minutes away...so I met him in my bathing suit, sans makeup and with wet hair.

Although I confirmed him at an earlier date, I was uninformed of his "thing" for heels, garters, and the whole Moulin Rouge look. Now, had I been aware of his preference AND had I some time to get out of the pool before he arrived, he may have scored me differently. BUT, 15 minute reviews are a WHOLE other subject! Lol!

I have recieved one 6 in appearance before.  The performance score on that particular review was a 10, so perhaps I wasn't his type of girl physically.  The rest of my appearance scores are 8's and 9's with a 7 here and there.  I agree, there is a big difference between a 6 and a 9.  This review was back when I worked with an agency, and while I do remember the session, I can't remember if perhaps I was maybe a bit rushed to get ready or what.  However, I am a pretty low-maintenance chick, and while I do put on sexy lingerie and heels, I am not big on a ton of makeup and the whole "Moulin Rouge" look as Caylee put it.  Unless you request that I am majorly done up, I'm going to open the door with minimal makeup and a smile.  Not to sound arrogant, but I don't think I am a 6.  Some guys just have very particular fantasies they've dreamed up, and are quite picky about the way a lady looks.  Three 6's and three 9's would confuse the hell out of me though.  Maybe check out the other reviews by those particular gents and see if they are relatively tough or maybe a little too easy going on their scores for other providers.

For instance, I know a lot of guys like skinny gals. I prefer someone with meat on her bones. Not huge, but with a real shape. So what might be a 6 for me might be a 9 for someone else. Also I have given a 7 to someone in the past when on a second visit I reassessed her to be of a 9. The first was an issue with her clothing and lighting. But performance was outstanding so I saw her again.

That is why multiple reviews are important. They tend to even things out from different perspectives.

That old adage still holds true---Beauty is in the eyes of the beholder.....

Question: Regardless of her appearance scores , were her performance scores relatively consistent?

If I wanted Nice in looks and Nice in performance, I'd shop at the dollar store. While taste do vary, there is a plethora of Attractive to Once in a Lifetime looking ladies (a lot of them just a PM away here on TER) that consistently provide a Hot Time to Once in a Lifetime experience.

6 and below has no reflection on the lady, it's just poor shopping by the reviewer. Come on guys, you had to do a little homework to pass school, do a little homework for your hobby. I do my homework on looks and for the other score, well we know how that works

In my eyes, Caylee, Alyssa and Elise couldn't be a 6 on their worst day.

Yes, everyone here seems to agree that opinions are subjective, but how do we take that and put it to use? While I know I am in no way a 6 (thanks to everyone else who thinks so too!) I also know that I'll never get a 10 (I'm working on the extra pounds but I don't think I'll ever get rid of that "Exit Only" sign on my rump!) So what do we do? Should TER add categories to the reviews? Like "BBW" or "Spinner"? Both types of ladies could be a 10 in a man's eyes and something completely different in someone else's.

If you rate her at a 6 and you new it going into it, then i guess that was the best in the area at the time. I know from traveling sometimes that's all that is available(6) on short notice in a small towns.