There is an agency lady that I have been really wanting to see. She has great reviews, looks just too cute to pass up and other guys have recommended her highly.

Now I just read a review for that agency which stated that there were lots of people in the incall. That is such a deal breaker for me. Last thing I want are lots of other people, ladies or hobbyists, milling around the place while I am trying to have fun.

I am just curious, is this a deal breaker for other guys as well?

Willy

some agencies want to create the feel of an old west brothel.  You know
have a drink get to know the girl etc.  I used to be skiddish about that but
i figure anybody at the place is there to fuck so what?

dealbreaker for me is misleading pictures.

The agencies I've visited in ATL have had other people in the apartment at the same time.
Usually it's a another gal sitting in the common area/living room. "Security?" or "witness?" or "watch out?" or "waiting?"... never really cared to ask. These ladies have always smiled at me and were hospitable when they did speak.
If other clients are there, the ladies are again discrete. The clients don't hear each other nor meet at all... at least I've never run into another client while entering/visiting/exiting an agency.

Have fun with your agency gal.

ga_kosh

It's not a big deal to me. As long as there are no disruptions or distractions I don't care if there are others in the apartment. I've never seen another guy when I was entering or leaving. I have occasionally heard the shower but that's nothing. I wouldn't want it to seem like a party with other people (guys) in the living area or kitchen. I don't mind seeing other ladies when entering or leaving.

an extra lady or two sitting around is one thing, extra guys sitting around sounds like a very busy incall and an easy place to draw too much attention. I have run into several guys over time.
I just ran into one the other day at an incell run by several independents. He practically jumped out of his skin. I guess it all boils down to what we are each comfortable with.

The agency that I've used generally has about 2-3 girls in the living room chilling out. No big deal. I look at it as maybe a safety in numbers situation. But, it also gives me a chance to see what other talents they're working with for my next adventure. But, if there was a bunch of other guys hanging out or a flat out party then I would be suspicious.

Maybe it depends on the agency.
Could be a case of Several Independents sharing space that may not have their collective acts together as an agency would. Independents look out for themselves sometimes and might not think of the other gals and their clients in the same regard. Kinda like having a Head Nurse coordinating the flow of patients through a treatment area so the clinic doesn't get hit with HIPAA violations for not making a"reasonable attempt" of privacy.
If you're uncomfortable with that agency, think about Outcall. If you've used them before, this should not be an issue.

Just my my ramblings.  Have fun.

As long as the guy's that are sitting around aren't reading guns & ammo or the police daily bulletin and wearing badges and handcuffs so what ??!!!!

The reviewer quotes

Only complaint is there were a lot of people in the apartment.

If we're talking a few i don't mind at all, however if we're talking a lot of people as the reviewer quotes then yes it's a deal breaker.
It all comes down to how much you value your privacy, perhaps you could pm the reviewer and ask him exactly how many people were in the apartment.    

You know beforehand that there are other gents in the place. It can be awkward for me when I run into you gents. Other ladies are definitely OK, in fact It's nice to see the girls.

LMAO AAHHHH YEP

Hell I'd buy you a session!!! But you better get a discount!!

It makes me unomfortble but i know sone guys like it. It wont stop me from making an appt but i find myself using the agencies where this doesnt happen the majority of the time.  At one agency ive run into other guys twice and i find that completely unacceptable