Maci,
What an excellent, thoughtful question. And good market research btw. And a possible peek into us gents' twisted minds.
These are just my thoughts, I can only answer for myself but generally the reason is...
1) She may not have enough reliable reviews. There are some newbies that I am interested in but I like to see several verifiable reviews before I take the leap. My TOFTT days are long behind me. Well, hopefully. Building a good provider reputation can take a while and sometimes that comes into play.
2) Like most guys I have time and budgetary constraints. I have limited timeslots and dollars to fill them up with lovely ladies. Sometimes I'm booked for a month out depending on my (and her) schedule. It's important for me to keep my commitments so it can sometimes be challenging to work in someone new. In fact, when I see someone new it's usually closely correlated to me receiving a last minute cancellation from someone else.
3) Sometimes our schedules just don't sync up. There are a couple of ladies that I've had on my radar for a while but it seems like they are busy when I'm free (and vice versa).
4) I like to do some research which involves reading reviews, backchanneling, and chatting up the ladies. Which I really like to do. Shocker.

Sometimes it can take a while before a girl makes it to the top of a gentleman's roster. And sometimes it can take a while before a guy finds that perfect next date.
And how long? It's hard to say. I've had some high dollar hotties on my list for a couple of years now. Lol. They are on my "when I hit the lotto I'm definitely going to see" list. Do those count?
Ah, we gents are such fickle creatures.
Excellent question, though.
-- Modified on 6/14/2016 12:59:25 PM