Suggestion and Policy

Def Need Neighborhood in NYC (and other big cities)
Br0wnst0ne 44 Reviews 2989 reads
posted

You folks who drive maybe never need more than the city, but NYC mongers take public transportation.  If I'm coming from downtown Brooklyn, it's a 30 to 40 minute train Southbound to get to Sheepshead Bay.  At night, it would be between one and two hours IN THE OPPOSITE DIRECTION and a half to get to Washington Heights.  You think it doesn't matter if it's going to take an extra hour to get there and another extra hour to get back?  Of course it does.  A system where only the city is mentioned would mean I call and bother 30 providers until I find one within a half hour distance.  That's silly when the neighborhood could just be listed.  There are between tens of thousands to hundreds of thousands of apartments in each NYC neighborhood.

Bootyhugs!3735 reads

I wonder if some of the review approvers are not familiar with NYC.  I did a review and said near a particular district or neighborhood that is dense and contains 40,000 to 60,000 residents (depending on whether you use wikipedia's borders or the community board's borders.)  Saying "near" this area probably includes about 80,000 residents.  And yet it was delayed for re-editing in case someone could use it to find the provider.  The intention is good, and maybe neighborhoods should not even be  mentioned in small towns, but there is no way to locate a person based on only hair color, breast size, and them using any one of 40,000 apartments.  Or am I missing something?

There really is no need to.  The review is about the lady and the appointment.  Maybe a bit about her in call is OK but definitely not the geography.  

Yes, there is, or at least once was, a fair amount of inconsistency in the review approval process. I'll never forget the review I saw four or five years ago that actually had a provider's hotel name and room number in the review!

You folks who drive maybe never need more than the city, but NYC mongers take public transportation.  If I'm coming from downtown Brooklyn, it's a 30 to 40 minute train Southbound to get to Sheepshead Bay.  At night, it would be between one and two hours IN THE OPPOSITE DIRECTION and a half to get to Washington Heights.  You think it doesn't matter if it's going to take an extra hour to get there and another extra hour to get back?  Of course it does.  A system where only the city is mentioned would mean I call and bother 30 providers until I find one within a half hour distance.  That's silly when the neighborhood could just be listed.  There are between tens of thousands to hundreds of thousands of apartments in each NYC neighborhood.

First, why is it so important to have the neighborhood in the review? Shouldn't the lady have it in her website, and ads? The review can just say "I saw her at her incall."
Second, how do you propose the folks in the Netherlands decide which cities are ok to list the neighborhood in reviews, and which ones are not?

Register Now!