I agree that filling out the profile every time you write a review is silly, especially when nothing changes on the profile without a problem report. I have posted on this myself and replied on other threads on this and other boards.
However, I think a review still should require some thought and work. Don't make it "too" easy. As it is, there are fake reviews written to get free VIP. Make it too easy and there will only be more. If you are still giving VIP days for reviews, then people should have to work a little for it. So hopefully there is some compromise on still having some work involved, but not having to refill the profile every single time. Good Luck.