So...who should gets nominated for the TER Award for Best Review writing?

and flame me. It's just my 2 cents. I find those posts exceedingly lengthy and the epitome of ennui.

Because I only read the ones that pertain to my area. I will say this though, I appreciate it when a hobbyist puts forth the effort to write a good, creative, funny review. That's what I try to do. Hate it when a new review pops up on a girl that I'm thinking of seeing, and it's two short paragraphs of nothing. Just my .02

NSF

You will have to extend the time of search.
Rooster's is the funniest,
Promeheus is the most eloquent writer
The most recent one (can't remember the author) is the best story.

Always looking for well written reviews - the best thing about this site IMO.

...had they anything whatsoever to with the thread at hand. In this context "who writes the best reviews" it was simply an unprovoked cheap shot.

Read between the lines of my post.  You had already said YOU thought JP's RFTF threads were boring.  I was CHALLENGING YOU to write something interesting yourself (which we who enjoy JP's writing would find interesting, too), and, as this was the only post under this alias for the previous 60 days, I assumed it was too difficult for you to do.

P.S.  Lisa Kudrow had it all over you, bones.

in her post "can you say" connotes "i learned a new word ".  I still personally don't understand how anyone can think JP's RFTF threads are boring, however you have to at the very least respect the writing.....courtney let me know if you want me to explain any of this to you....

... all 82 of them at last count!

He has helped me in the backchannel as well, especially with some PSE advice. From my experience, his reviews have always told an accurate tale.