I also completely agree with your major premise; give me a less attractive woman who is really into it than a 10 who thinks she can just lie there any day of the week. My top 10, in ascending order of "into-it-ness":
10) Venus: Such a hot mess as well, proverbial escort with a heart of gold. Venus had great sound bite when I was fucking her in the ass: "Don't you fucking cum yet!" Umm, ok but soon that's not going to be volitional!
9) Riley Shye: Great body, great attitude, all on her own rolled on her back, dropped her head over the edge of the bed and told me to skull fuck her.
8) Queeny: Came up to my room at AVN to finish up what another girl had started but then passed out. She walked in, kissed me long and deep, then said "ooh, I love the taste of pussy." She also said I have "yummy dick."
7) Ashley Shye/Mia Domore: Hard to separate these two since the three of us spent our time together. It was quite the evening, since these are two of the most enthusiastic cock suckers I've encountered. Not only did they seem to enjoy doing it themselves, they also appeared to get off on watching each other.
6) Alexandra Quinn: Spent a lot of time with Alex when she was still in LA about 10 years ago (we kinda had a thing, not really sure how to describe it, more than just dating but not quite bf/gf) and she brought it every time. Was part of the best single experience ever, discussed below.
5) Alana Evans: My very first PSE, fortunately able to hook up during the 15 or 20 minutes that she was escorting openly. We watched some of her scenes while we played, recreating some of my favorites. Both laughed like hell when in one of the scenes she said something about how much she loves giving head and it was exactly what she had just told me a few minutes before.
4) RayVeness: Spent a lot time with Ray as well a few years ago, very interesting, intense woman. She also brought it every time we played, great attitude and eye contact.
3) Claire Dames: Still buddies with Claire, who as amazing right out of the box. That first time we hooked up, she acted like we were long lost lovers, reuniting after years of separation.
2) Ryan Conner: Ryan may be this high on the list because she's the most recent but damn this woman is amazing. So smart, so chill and soooo talented.
1) Nikita Denise: Still my ATF, alone or with someone else (Ryan, Alexandra, Claire, Kiki Daire leap to mind), Nikita has been incredible every time. The two best sound bites ever are from the first time we played with Alexandra: Early on the festivities, I made a gentle suggestion as to what I thought should be occurring, to which I was told, "Ve know vhat we're doing, darhling!" Right, right, you don't come down to the car wash to tell me how to do my job. She was right, it was like being with a well-choreographed gymnastics team, one with a major oral fixation. My favorite sound bite came a bit later when I was told, "Don't stop, darling, I think she's close!" The afternoon culminated with me standing next to the bed, Alexandra on all fours in front of me, taking me balls deep while Nikita buried her tongue in her ass, locking eyes with me the entire time. I almost passed out when I came.
I know that is more than what's called for by your post but at this upper echelon, the qualitative differences between #1 and #10 is so small as to be almost impossible to differentiate. No wonder I'm such a good mood most of the time.
It's my one regret that she was killed before I could take her up on her offer.
