Legal Corner

Legalize Prostitution
AnjieLina See my TER Reviews 9520 reads
posted

Ladies & Gentlemen what is your opinion on Legalizing Prostitution?

Partial article I found to be interesting....

Some researchers say a reason for the inordinate amount of police attention to prostitution is that certain officers prefer duties enabling them to be with attractive women in hotel rooms or massage parlors. The duties are more pleasant, far less dangerous, and less complex than assignments requiring them to be among violent criminals who may be carrying weapons.

For instance, in 1999 at least one of the vice-squad officers in Columbus, Ohio, was regularly having sexual intercourse with prostitutes before arresting them. After receiving negative publicity about that practice, the police division issued new guidelines limiting officers to getting completely naked with prostitutes; touching their thigh, genitals, buttock, pubic region, breast, or other regions to the extent needed "to obtain the necessary elements of the offense"; being masturbated briefly; and "momentarily" having sexual intercourse if it's "in spite of all reasonable efforts of the officer to stop." (In practice, though, the officers apparently find it necessary to use those tactics only in arresting female - not male - prostitutes.)

Despite the revised guidelines, in 2003 the Columbus Dispatch quoted one court clerk as describing the officers' arrest reports as sometimes being so steamy she "should have a cigarette after reading it." The head of the vice squad acknowledged to the newspaper that "it appears officers are engaging in sexual contact."

His officers give new meaning to being "in hot pursuit." Unfortunately for the public, this nonsense goes on at the same time that Columbus has over 400 unsolved murders since 1990, including several prostitutes brutally murdered by a possible serial killer. When a frightened group of senior citizens and disabled persons asked in 2004 for more protection from violent crime, the Columbus police chief turned them down, saying, "Seventy-eight times a day we are unable to fill a cruiser because of lack of personnel."

As for white-collar crime, the police undoubtedly know that their jobs and careers are safer by making prostitution arrests than by investigating criminals who cause serious harm but either wield political power or have strong connections to those who do. And when the corruption involves others in the police force, the notorious "Blue Wall of Silence" leads all too many officers to ignore and protect the wrongdoing of badge-wearing criminals, too.  



-- Modified on 4/5/2006 9:11:14 AM

sidone7493 reads

If police could decide what is legal and what isn't then it might make sense to say prostitution is a crime so that police can have this kind of fun.  But of course that's not how it works.  

Legislators have criminalized prostitution because of our society's puritanical views on sex and because they believe it has a pernicious impact on society.  These motivations won't change because of police misconduct related to enforcing the laws against prostitution.  

The fact that vice cops often take advantage of their positions is reason to reform the way they operate but not to legalize prostitution, just as the fact that many narcotics officers are on the take is no reason to legalize drugs.  

I generally believe "vice" crimes should be abolished and I can offer many other arguments to support my position, but this particular argument doesn't strike me as a very good one.

Mister Spock6658 reads

the complaint here is about procedure, not substance.

Register Now!