agree with your John for the most part. I love a natural-looking gal with little to no makeup.

Too much makes a chick look like a circus clown

women are almost always more attractive to me without make up. Some of the most attractive women to me were always more so clean and natural. I know women never believe this, just like almost every woman I know thinks she is over weight, but it is true.

As the saying goes. Natural is my preference although I realize many ladies are not comfotable presenting themselves this way.

HuffPo did a slide show on porn stars before & after makeup was done a couple of years ago. Whatever the point of the exercise was, I found myself gravitating toward those who looked best without, though I'll confess that my 'winners' were the ones who looked really cute rather than really hot. Bree Olson did a particularly disheveled Before pose that was especially adorable. My biological response to adult cuteness is a desire to plow the cutie. My biological response to heavy makeup (no matter how hot) is to wonder what's being concealed by it.

Having declared my bias, I'll also admit that there are women in my life that are more desirable after theyve tended to themselves. But they're the exceptions.

Biggest sin is generally way too much eye makeup, or just the wrong eye makeup for that person.

I have to say less make up is good most women cake it on but that isn't sexy do you really want to have your make up all over someone else in my opinion

I like long thick fake eyelashes, smoky eye shadow, yeah definitely makeup for a P4P date.  

If I was going to a ballgame on a non P4P date, then no makeup maybe is in order. Otherwise I like the glam'd up look.

Among other things, I'm concerned about "transfer" and anything I might not catch in a final shower and clean up before I leave the room and return to real life.  

I feel I have been very fortunate to have met many beauties who don't need a lot of make-up. Some eye makeup, maybe even false eyelashes, is very common but not much else (as far as I can tell).  

If I was planning some special fantasy (some guys want lots of red lipstick transferred to their pecker; some guys want to smear makeup all over their hostess's face), I might ask for more. In general, I prefer little or no makeup

Thank you for bringing up the topic!!
As a provider, I try my best to consider the desires of my friends, and this is one piece of the puzzle where I use my own best judgment.  Am I wearing too much; not enough make-up?

Feedback and comments welcome!!... Is it wierd to as my friend his preference?  

In my corporate life, I wear blush, light gloss, and mascara... Very UTR look.  

Looking forward to your opinion!!

Krista

Whatever the provider feels more comfortable with. Light or heavy makeup is fine with me. I can't ever remember seeing a provider who had no makeup on. I'm sure it would be a shock, only because it's so rare, but I could roll with it.

Girls I regular with apply minimal or no make-up.  It's just going to end up all over the sheets anyway.

more sexy. Similar to what she wears.

I could care less about both but if it makes the date better for her;  
I'm all for it!

I like COF, and of course, a gal who has just spent an hour doing up her face is going to regard my request with about the same consideration as if I asked her to let me watch her get gang-banged by the Hell's Angels.  (Come to think of it, a few gals have expressed some interest in that, but you know what I mean.)

Anyhoo:

There are other concerns.  Back when I was married, I was concerned that her makeup would find its way onto my clothing thus causing the meme to grow suspicious.  It's as bad as perfume that way.

That said, I will admit that most gals do look better with makeup, assuming they are skilled at applying it (Some aren't.),  but on a one to ten scale, this facet of their skills rates about a 3 - it's just not a big deal to me.  I've never seen a gal without makeup and said to myself:  "Yuck, no way I can be with her anymore.)

Then there is the waiting around while she gets ready to go out to dinner factor.  (Just another five minutes which invariably becomes 30.)  I've missed more than a few reservations on account of Max Factor.  

All and all, makeup is one of society's more dubious achievements

Once I have decided to spend time with a lady, I am choosing her because she is first attractive to me and then everything else lines up with reviews etc.... If she shows her face in her pictures and she has a lot of make up on I will pass no matter the reviews and her stats. If she does not show her face I use my judgement.  

I also request no make up but some ladies like to wear a little on the first date. When they prefer to wear some as they feel more confident, I am good with it as long as it is minimal. I am perfectly fine with their imperfections if they have some as I am there because I want to be with her and blemishes or marks that are covered by make up do not bother me. I actually find her more attractive without as it exudes confidence.

Leave it off ladies, leave it off.

I prefer little or no makeup.  Natural is the way to go...

I personally love tons of makeup.   I guess it's just preference.  It's a huge turn on for me when I see a girl go all out and have the pornstar slutty look

I think most women look better in their natural state, but every now and then I like my ladies to spice things up and go for the "slutty" look: tons of makeup, fishnet stockings, see-through clothing, and so on.