It should come as no surprise it was number three for me, with a bit of number one tossed in. I don't think any guy has any idea how to properly eat a pussy his first time trying. It doesn't help when said pussy and all it's sweetness is hidden under layers and layers of hair.

I don't think I got any good at eating pussy, nor did I really care to do so until I was well into my thirties after women had learned that razor weren't just for their legs and pits, but once I hit my stride it has become one of my favorite activities and 6-7-8 and 9 all apply to me today.

Hooked

Probably 18-19 years old.  

First serious girlfriend could only cum from oral. So she had me...  eat her after I finished up. Sometimes it was a bit annoying. Someone always seemed to end up slightly unsatisfied..  

She gave great directions so I suppose I got good at it quickly.

Still one of my favorite activities. 7,8.9.  Nothing gets me going faster for round two.

with questions and insecurities running thru my mind ... am I going this right? Well? Great? Is she enjoying this? And more. Didn't stop me from a second romp in the forest tho ... for me, a session isn't a session without DATY ...

I don't do if for the taste, though I don't find it unpleasant. I love to hear the reaction I get from a well placed tongue.

But the first time I went down on my college GF it was 7. Possibly because that woman was way into it and she was a blast to make cum. I've never had a woman since who was that vocal, active and who shuddered and was flushed when she came. She made sure she got hers, I'll never forget when I would get between her legs and start to go down on her, she'd reach out, grab me by the back of my head and pretty much use me as a masturbation tool which had a moveable tongue, I loved every minute.

Is there a 10

I was young (13) with an older friend (17) that I was in total lust with and she was very helpful in guiding me.  She had me watch her masterbate first so I could get my 1st taste of pure, undiluted with my saliva, cum - before diving in for the oral pleasure.  

I was hooked from the start - 6, 7, 8, 9, 10+  All apply to me

but obviously, I wasn't doing it right.

The gal, my first girl friend and someone with a lengthy sexual history already, told me to quit fooling around down there and get my dick in her so she can have some fun

But I didn't care at the time, because at least it didn't taste bad, and her reactions to my tongue were quite exciting.

I hate to say it but some ladies just smell and taste nasty down there.

Others taste wonderful.  

When it's the latter, I can just bury my head in her muff for hours, only coming up for air and a sip of water.

For me it was a 4 but for my GF oh yeah she got a 10 lol E

EOM

It was so hot my skull almost popped off.

It was my favorite part of intimacy, even before I had experienced complete intimacy. And still is.

therefore 3 is definitely on the list, plus 1, probably 2, and 6, 7, & 9 for sure.

When I was young, I used to get calls from a neighborhood girl inviting me to come over and play. The vast majority of the time we'd play board games, watch tv, or just hang out. If I ever hesitated, for whatever reason, she would entice me by saying she'd let me see her pussy. Damn you girls! You learn early. One might think I would have hesitated every time, but no. One time she said she'd let me f*ck her. Impossible for a prepubescent kid. But one day, and only once, I got to taste that crazy pussy. We were down at the tree, it was dark, and I got on my knees. It had a pungent taste, but I really liked it, a 5 if you will. It was the first time I had a rush of passion. The other thing is that it hard wired my brain into a love for eating pussy. I've had sessions, if a lady could handle it, and most cannot, where the whole hour was nothing but daty.  

Now I've progressed up beyond a 9. Now I'm a 10. A 10 is when the lady does something so unusual during a session, you know she's not faking. Always an interesting scenario in the escort world. And it usually happens during daty. Of course, if they are wet (soaking wet sheets for the hour daty session), that's a dead give away. But sometimes it's the sounds they make. If they growl, giggle, hum, sing, purr, or do a squirming whir, you know you've got something there. Most fakers think all they need to do is the proverbial Meg Ryan porn moan. C'mon! If you're a 10, you know the difference (if you give me the porn moan, I shall not return)(the fake porn moan is all in the eyes, and eyes don't lie). Now if a lady tells you how good you are down there, she's faking. But if her actions match what she says, she's not. If she answers the door naked, and wants you on your knees before it's shut, that's not faking. Or if she pulls you on the bed to kiss her naked pussy, before either of you have taken you're clothes off, and keeps you there until she cums, she's not (then you take your shower so the session can proceed). If she hops in the shower with you, and insists you get on your knees again, she's not. If you're literally on your way out the door after the session, and she says, 'will you hit me (otc daty) just once more', she's not faking. If an invitation to spend the night comes right after a long daty cum, I'm pretty sure she wasn't faking. All of that is called spontaneity. And lastly, if she bangs her arms against the walls during daty, you know you've hit a 10. There's no escort in the world who will fake arm bang. Even the best escort fake cum actresses won't arm bang. Too painful. When I find ladies who do any, some, or all of the above, I can't get back fast enough! Those are the ladies who get my tens of thousands of dollars.

Easily an 8 or 9 for me...

One of my first girlfriends. I was 15, she was 17. I don't know if it is the taste per se, or simply the sense of power and control to make her cum. Both are amazing on their own, the combination is transcendant.  

I've been a DATY fan forever after.