Politics and Religion

Well for one, people associate prostitution with ...
CltLuvr 474 reads
posted

STD's, along with being an underground economy that evades income tax, not to mention parents with daughters

rainy_days1985 reads

I've not really delved far into the issue, but it is my feeling that public opinion (in the US) is pretty strongly opposed to legalized prostitution. Of course the public follows wherever it is led, so I'm wondering, what are the institutions driving the belief that prostitution is degrading and evil?

First thing that comes to mind is the Church, but it seems to me this country is growing more and more secular, and yet the hatred of prostitution remains. Also it occurred to me that throughout European (and probably world) history, prostitution has flourished even while religion hovered near zenith of its power. I wonder why modern America is different.

The "gender wars" in this country is a mess I hate to step into, but I feel it is probably relevant to this issue. The demonization of the male and the supposed empowerment of women seems to encourage the idea that the explicit sale of sex is yet another form of male victimizing female.  

Lastly I think that individuals selling sex cuts into the profit of big business. One of the greatest selling tools is exciting and then exploiting the sexual urge. Everywhere in advertising and media we are tantalized with the image of sex, and being barred from buying the thing itself, we can only spend on the products we are made to associate with it. To make people spend endlessly, they must be kept hungry and dissatisfied... thus sex loses its power as a selling tool if people are allowed to fulfill their urges.

Anyway those are my thoughts. I'm curious to hear what others think of this subject.

CltLuvr475 reads

STD's, along with being an underground economy that evades income tax, not to mention parents with daughters

Parents and daughters I can understand, but don't the other two become a problem precisely because it is illegal?

Whatever two consenting adults do in private is not. If prostitution were legal... It would be mainstream. There would be ads for it on TV. You would be approached by street walkers everywhere you went. Families would be walking past guys getting blow jobs in ally ways. Do you really want that?

Whether it should or shouldn't be legal is another (interesting) question. I was just curious first of all why it is not. Is it true that in places where it is legal, it's being advertised on TV and blowjobs are rampant in the ally ways? It sounds like exaggeration to me but I honestly don't know.

How "hypocritical" would that slogan sound if prostitution were legal in America?

 

Posted By: rainy_days
Whether it should or shouldn't be legal is another (interesting) question. I was just curious first of all why it is not. Is it true that in places where it is legal, it's being advertised on TV and blowjobs are rampant in the ally ways? It sounds like exaggeration to me but I honestly don't know.

GaGambler311 reads

I go to many countries where prostitution has been legal for a very long time, and none of what has been described here has happened in any of the couple of dozen other countries where I have enjoyed legal prostitution.

Your common sense has given you much better answers than idle speculation from a couple of closeted bible thumpers have so far.

In a long history of dense, nonsensical and simply idiotic posts his is, well, just one more.

Why do women leave their home countries where prostitution is legal and come to the U.S.?

I don't think they would come here if prostitution were legal.

The OP ask what was the largest force keeping prostitution illegal in the U.S.?

Posted By: inicky46
In a long history of dense, nonsensical and simply idiotic posts his is, well, just one more.

You think there's a single answer to your inane question, but in fact there are several.
1) Many women in countries where prostitution is legal don't come here.
2) Those who do have reasons like,
  a) They want to see this country.
  b) The US is where the money is.  They can work for a few months, take the money and go home for a while. I personally know several who have done this.
So why would they not come here if it were legal?  That would simply be one more inducement.  Your implication seems to be that women come here because its Illegal, which is obtuse.  What a shock.

Posted By: inicky46
 
   b) The US is where the money is.  They can work for a few months, take the money and go home for a while.
The fact that it is illegal here, is why it is lucrative. It would not be as lucrative if it were legal, because there would be even more providers in the market place driving down prices, to the level you see in places where it is legal.  

Which actually wasn't the point of my original comment. My original comment was that the legalization of prostitution. Would not coincide with the slogans of the U.S. ... and we both know slogans are more important than people's rights.

Very few women have the balls to do this job.  Even in Costa Rica where it's legal.  Your last sentence was incomprehensible.  Which is what we expect.

I don't really care why or why it isn't legal. I accept the situation for what it is, and live accordingly unlike the overactive mentally retarded minds here.

I doubt it.  Now go clean the drool from your keyboard, SPOAT.

Prostitution is legal in Amsterdam yet you would be hard pressed to witness BJ's in a narrow walkway between two buildings, with the exception, behind closed doors in a Red Light alley.
 
   Partaking of Cannabis is  not a criminal offense for Dutch citizens in Holland, yet  you would have  more  difficultly finding  citizens  smoking cannabis on public streets in Amsterdam, than you would in major U.S. cities.
   
  Unfortunately, many ignorant people in America believe rudeness accompanied by a  thug demeanor is a prerequisite to the cool factor .  
  Little do they know, they present themselves to many others, as  truly ignorant uncivilized fools.
 
  A Gentlemen or an intelligent heathen in any country, would never blow cannabis smoke or receive a BJ in public, in  the proximity of Mothers, Grandmas or children, or in private, near children.
   
   In private it's fine to have your kind of fun, with any willing Mom or Grannie you might find, even when your friends don't find her attractive.  :-D
   
       

Posted By: User1994
Whatever two consenting adults do in private is not. If prostitution were legal... It would be mainstream. There would be ads for it on TV. You would be approached by street walkers everywhere you went. Families would be walking past guys getting blow jobs in ally ways. Do you really want that?

Posted By: quadseasonal
Prostitution is legal in Amsterdam yet you would be hard pressed to witness BJ's in a narrow walkway between two buildings, with the exception, behind closed doors in a Red Light alley.  
   
    Partaking of Cannabis is  not a criminal offense for Dutch citizens in Holland, yet  you would have  more  difficultly finding  citizens  smoking cannabis on public streets in Amsterdam, than you would in major U.S. cities.  
     
   Unfortunately, many ignorant people in America believe rudeness accompanied by a  thug demeanor is a prerequisite to the cool factor .  
   Little do they know, they present themselves to many others, as  truly ignorant uncivilized fools.  
   
   A Gentlemen or an intelligent heathen in any country, would never blow cannabis smoke or receive a BJ in public, in  the proximity of Mothers, Grandmas or children, or in private, near children.  
     
    In private it's fine to have your kind of fun, with any willing Mom or Grannie you might find, even when your friends don't find her attractive.  :-D
Amsterdam resident for a few years now with some points to make - firstly, smoking cannabis is illegal, however the law is not enforced. I used to buy my weed from a place that was, no exaggeration, 50 yards from a police station - you could see one building from the window of the other, and vice versa. I have handed a 3g bag to a police officer who passed it back to me and told me to enjoy. Possession of more than 5 grams or 5 plants will get you busted though - the exceptions being licensed coffee shops where it is legal to sell, however even collecting product from growers is exceptionally murky legally speaking. Similarly in these coffee shops it's also not legal to smoke tobacco, and the fines are quite incredibly harsh for the shop if they get caught.  

To say that you would have difficulty finding citizens smoking weed in the streets just demonstrates that you have never been to this remarkable, odd city. In other cities in the Netherlands it's certainly a lot less likely, but in the centre of Amsterdam it's pretty easy to walk down the street, take a deep breath, and be able to figure out which tourist isn't smoking just tobacco.

As for the red light district/cannabis and mothers, grandmothers and children - I've seen it all. It's not at all uncommon to see a young child walking around the red light district with his/her parents, and again, as this is where all the tourists are, so is the weed. You cannot move for large parties of older tourists, mostly Asian, in the same area.  

Bottom line is, not everything is as you might think until you see it for yourself. Still no BJs down alleyways though.

I originally wrote technically legal, edited  out legal before posting, to avoid confusion.
 Changed my original line to "not a criminal defense" .  
.  
 No matter what, there are  always  those  easily confused with technicalities, while grasping at thin straws .  
   75% of the coffee shops in Amsterdam sell cannabis.  
 
   I said  you would have  "MORE  difficultly finding  citizens  smoking cannabis on public streets in Amsterdam, than you would in major U.S. cities"
  By citizens I was speaking of  Dutch citizens, not tourasses from America or other foreigners with no respect for their surroundings and foreign lands they visit.  

    There are exceptions to every generalization. One of the points I stand by, as a whole the Dutch are more civilized and polite than Americans, with the exception of some Dutch soccer fans .  

    The families you see in the Red Light district with children are rarely Dutch citizens.  

    You should get out a little more, early morning, late night during the week, when  the Friday Saturday older Asian crowds who block your view and movement are somewhere else.
   
  I might be wrong, everything I learned about Amsterdam I heard from a Dutch GF who moved to Hoboken U.S.A after working in the  Amsterdam red light district and bordellos in Rotterdam, a house boat bordello in Ultrecht , a members only bordello in Alkmaar.  
   She moved to America when the last place she was working, Yab Yum was closed.  
   
   She never complained about older Asians on Asian night, only  Turks on Turkey night.

     Bottom line, what some believe is a  demonstration of  truth, is often much farther from reality
than they  imagine.   :-D

       

Posted By: GiantBombing
 
Posted By: quadseasonal
Prostitution is legal in Amsterdam yet you would be hard pressed to witness BJ's in a narrow walkway between two buildings, with the exception, behind closed doors in a Red Light alley.  
     
     Partaking of Cannabis is  not a criminal offense for Dutch citizens in Holland, yet  you would have  more  difficultly finding  citizens  smoking cannabis on public streets in Amsterdam, than you would in major U.S. cities.  
       
    Unfortunately, many ignorant people in America believe rudeness accompanied by a  thug demeanor is a prerequisite to the cool factor .    
    Little do they know, they present themselves to many others, as  truly ignorant uncivilized fools.  
     
    A Gentlemen or an intelligent heathen in any country, would never blow cannabis smoke or receive a BJ in public, in  the proximity of Mothers, Grandmas or children, or in private, near children.  
       
     In private it's fine to have your kind of fun, with any willing Mom or Grannie you might find, even when your friends don't find her attractive.  :-D
   
 Amsterdam resident for a few years now with some points to make - firstly, smoking cannabis is illegal, however the law is not enforced. I used to buy my weed from a place that was, no exaggeration, 50 yards from a police station - you could see one building from the window of the other, and vice versa. I have handed a 3g bag to a police officer who passed it back to me and told me to enjoy. Possession of more than 5 grams or 5 plants will get you busted though - the exceptions being licensed coffee shops where it is legal to sell, however even collecting product from growers is exceptionally murky legally speaking. Similarly in these coffee shops it's also not legal to smoke tobacco, and the fines are quite incredibly harsh for the shop if they get caught.  
   
 To say that you would have difficulty finding citizens smoking weed in the streets just demonstrates that you have never been to this remarkable, odd city. In other cities in the Netherlands it's certainly a lot less likely, but in the centre of Amsterdam it's pretty easy to walk down the street, take a deep breath, and be able to figure out which tourist isn't smoking just tobacco.  
   
 As for the red light district/cannabis and mothers, grandmothers and children - I've seen it all. It's not at all uncommon to see a young child walking around the red light district with his/her parents, and again, as this is where all the tourists are, so is the weed. You cannot move for large parties of older tourists, mostly Asian, in the same area.  
   
 Bottom line is, not everything is as you might think until you see it for yourself. Still no BJs down alleyways though.

Posted By: quadseasonal
  I originally wrote technically legal, edited  out legal before posting, to avoid confusion.  
  Changed my original line to "not a criminal defense" .  
 .  
  No matter what, there are  always  those  easily confused with technicalities, while grasping at thin straws .    
    75% of the coffee shops in Amsterdam sell cannabis.  
   
    I said  you would have  "MORE  difficultly finding  citizens  smoking cannabis on public streets in Amsterdam, than you would in major U.S. cities"  
   By citizens I was speaking of  Dutch citizens, not tourasses from America or other foreigners with no respect for their surroundings and foreign lands they visit.  
   
     There are exceptions to every generalization. One of the points I stand by, as a whole the Dutch are more civilized and polite than Americans, with the exception of some Dutch soccer fans .  
   
     The families you see in the Red Light district with children are rarely Dutch citizens.  
   
     You should get out a little more, early morning, late night during the week, when  the Friday Saturday older Asian crowds who block your view and movement are somewhere else.  
     
   I might be wrong, everything I learned about Amsterdam I heard from a Dutch GF who moved to Hoboken U.S.A after working in the  Amsterdam red light district and bordellos in Rotterdam, a house boat bordello in Ultrecht , a members only bordello in Alkmaar.  
    She moved to America when the last place she was working, Yab Yum was closed.  
     
    She never complained about older Asians on Asian night, only  Turks on Turkey night.  
   
      Bottom line, what some believe is a  demonstration of  truth, is often much farther from reality  
 than they  imagine.   :-D  
   
         
   
Posted By: GiantBombing
 
Posted By: quadseasonal
Prostitution is legal in Amsterdam yet you would be hard pressed to witness BJ's in a narrow walkway between two buildings, with the exception, behind closed doors in a Red Light alley.    
       
      Partaking of Cannabis is  not a criminal offense for Dutch citizens in Holland, yet  you would have  more  difficultly finding  citizens  smoking cannabis on public streets in Amsterdam, than you would in major U.S. cities.    
         
     Unfortunately, many ignorant people in America believe rudeness accompanied by a  thug demeanor is a prerequisite to the cool factor .    
     Little do they know, they present themselves to many others, as  truly ignorant uncivilized fools.    
       
     A Gentlemen or an intelligent heathen in any country, would never blow cannabis smoke or receive a BJ in public, in  the proximity of Mothers, Grandmas or children, or in private, near children.    
         
      In private it's fine to have your kind of fun, with any willing Mom or Grannie you might find, even when your friends don't find her attractive.  :-D
 
     
  Amsterdam resident for a few years now with some points to make - firstly, smoking cannabis is illegal, however the law is not enforced. I used to buy my weed from a place that was, no exaggeration, 50 yards from a police station - you could see one building from the window of the other, and vice versa. I have handed a 3g bag to a police officer who passed it back to me and told me to enjoy. Possession of more than 5 grams or 5 plants will get you busted though - the exceptions being licensed coffee shops where it is legal to sell, however even collecting product from growers is exceptionally murky legally speaking. Similarly in these coffee shops it's also not legal to smoke tobacco, and the fines are quite incredibly harsh for the shop if they get caught.    
     
  To say that you would have difficulty finding citizens smoking weed in the streets just demonstrates that you have never been to this remarkable, odd city. In other cities in the Netherlands it's certainly a lot less likely, but in the centre of Amsterdam it's pretty easy to walk down the street, take a deep breath, and be able to figure out which tourist isn't smoking just tobacco.  
     
  As for the red light district/cannabis and mothers, grandmothers and children - I've seen it all. It's not at all uncommon to see a young child walking around the red light district with his/her parents, and again, as this is where all the tourists are, so is the weed. You cannot move for large parties of older tourists, mostly Asian, in the same area.    
     
  Bottom line is, not everything is as you might think until you see it for yourself. Still no BJs down alleyways though.
Yep, I love being told how the city I live is by someone who hasn't set foot in it. Quite a bit of your information here is at best outdated and at worst completely incorrect, but whatever. Let's not hijack this post with what is essentially a glorified TripAdvisor post.

Perhaps I  have lived a more sheltered, easily influenced  life than I imagined  
   .  
  I had no reason to suspect  my Dutch ex GF would  lie to me about the  Dutch  civilized nature, congeniality, and  respect toward other peoples feelings, until now.  
       
    According to you it looks like the joke is on me.  
     
     I had to google TripAdvisor, never been there.    
        Nice site Bro, thanks  for  the traveling tip.  
     
   If I'm ever able to  save enough money to travel outside Hoboken I'll be sure to check  
  out  TripAdvisor  first,  if I don't eat  space cake and forget before I purchase tickets .   :-D

  Since this thread has already been hijacked too much for my liking, if you don't mind,  
  PM me with everything I posted you found to be "completely incorrect".  
   
  If you don't care to PM , feel free to post my "completely incorrect" statements for all to see.
              I will give you the benefit of last word.    
 
  I don't want to  bore the board any more than they are, with one guys view on  a country  and people, based on talks with his  ex GF, and the other foreigner learning of Amsterdam  confined to  his comfort zone experiences .

  No sense in me carrying on about somewhere I've never been.
          Outdated or not, I am always willing to learn.    :-D

Posted By: GiantBombing
 
   
Posted By: quadseasonal
  I originally wrote technically legal, edited  out legal before posting, to avoid confusion.  
   Changed my original line to "not a criminal defense" .    
  .    
   No matter what, there are  always  those  easily confused with technicalities, while grasping at thin straws .    
     75% of the coffee shops in Amsterdam sell cannabis.    
     
     I said  you would have  "MORE  difficultly finding  citizens  smoking cannabis on public streets in Amsterdam, than you would in major U.S. cities"  
    By citizens I was speaking of  Dutch citizens, not tourasses from America or other foreigners with no respect for their surroundings and foreign lands they visit.    
     
      There are exceptions to every generalization. One of the points I stand by, as a whole the Dutch are more civilized and polite than Americans, with the exception of some Dutch soccer fans .    
     
      The families you see in the Red Light district with children are rarely Dutch citizens.    
     
      You should get out a little more, early morning, late night during the week, when  the Friday Saturday older Asian crowds who block your view and movement are somewhere else.  
       
    I might be wrong, everything I learned about Amsterdam I heard from a Dutch GF who moved to Hoboken U.S.A after working in the  Amsterdam red light district and bordellos in Rotterdam, a house boat bordello in Ultrecht , a members only bordello in Alkmaar.    
     She moved to America when the last place she was working, Yab Yum was closed.    
       
     She never complained about older Asians on Asian night, only  Turks on Turkey night.  
     
       Bottom line, what some believe is a  demonstration of  truth, is often much farther from reality  
  than they  imagine.   :-D  
     
           
     
Posted By: GiantBombing
   
   
Posted By: quadseasonal
Prostitution is legal in Amsterdam yet you would be hard pressed to witness BJ's in a narrow walkway between two buildings, with the exception, behind closed doors in a Red Light alley.    
         
       Partaking of Cannabis is  not a criminal offense for Dutch citizens in Holland, yet  you would have  more  difficultly finding  citizens  smoking cannabis on public streets in Amsterdam, than you would in major U.S. cities.    
           
      Unfortunately, many ignorant people in America believe rudeness accompanied by a  thug demeanor is a prerequisite to the cool factor .      
      Little do they know, they present themselves to many others, as  truly ignorant uncivilized fools.    
         
      A Gentlemen or an intelligent heathen in any country, would never blow cannabis smoke or receive a BJ in public, in  the proximity of Mothers, Grandmas or children, or in private, near children.    
           
       In private it's fine to have your kind of fun, with any willing Mom or Grannie you might find, even when your friends don't find her attractive.  :-D
   
       
   Amsterdam resident for a few years now with some points to make - firstly, smoking cannabis is illegal, however the law is not enforced. I used to buy my weed from a place that was, no exaggeration, 50 yards from a police station - you could see one building from the window of the other, and vice versa. I have handed a 3g bag to a police officer who passed it back to me and told me to enjoy. Possession of more than 5 grams or 5 plants will get you busted though - the exceptions being licensed coffee shops where it is legal to sell, however even collecting product from growers is exceptionally murky legally speaking. Similarly in these coffee shops it's also not legal to smoke tobacco, and the fines are quite incredibly harsh for the shop if they get caught.    
       
   To say that you would have difficulty finding citizens smoking weed in the streets just demonstrates that you have never been to this remarkable, odd city. In other cities in the Netherlands it's certainly a lot less likely, but in the centre of Amsterdam it's pretty easy to walk down the street, take a deep breath, and be able to figure out which tourist isn't smoking just tobacco.    
       
   As for the red light district/cannabis and mothers, grandmothers and children - I've seen it all. It's not at all uncommon to see a young child walking around the red light district with his/her parents, and again, as this is where all the tourists are, so is the weed. You cannot move for large parties of older tourists, mostly Asian, in the same area.    
       
   Bottom line is, not everything is as you might think until you see it for yourself. Still no BJs down alleyways though.
   
 Yep, I love being told how the city I live is by someone who hasn't set foot in it. Quite a bit of your information here is at best outdated and at worst completely incorrect, but whatever. Let's not hijack this post with what is essentially a glorified TripAdvisor post.

I attempted to offer a "short" answer previously, but even that turned into an essay. So I'll attempt an even shorter one now that will clearly not cover most of my thoughts on the subject.

The main force I see opposing legalization is emotion. All opposing arguments to legalization are, at their core, illogical and emotion-based. Just look at one of the responses you got here from a hobbyist no less: "If prostitution were legal... It would be mainstream. There would be ads for it on TV. You would be approached by street walkers everywhere you went. Families would be walking past guys getting blow jobs in ally ways. Do you really want that?"

Unless he was being facetious, that response has absolutely no basis in reality or logic. It's an emotional reaction . . . "do you really want to walk your family past people getting blow jobs?" Of course not, but that's a slippery slope fallacy. There's no logic or evidence to support the claim that legalizing prostitution would lead to a dystopia where blow jobs are had out in the open on every street corner in front of children.  Other arguments claim that STDs would plague us, that it's immoral, that it would legalize pedophilia and sex trafficking. It's all meritless, illogical, emotion-based nonsense (and almost all of them are also fallacious in the same way as above). And you can't argue against emotion with logic. It's futile

GaGambler411 reads

and everyone knows I am as "anti church" as anyone who has ever posted on this board.

The truth of the matter however is that in many other countries, MANY others, the Church and legalized prostitution coexist quite nicely together. Take virtually every country in Central or South America for example. Almost every country there is dominated by the Catholic Church, yet in all most every Latin American country prostitution is perfectly legal with NONE of the problems speculated by the nay sayers here.

I appreciate you sharing your experience (not just here but in other threads). Speculation easily can go far astray without experience to chime in.

I think religion is only one component of it. Cultural perceptions, perhaps, might outweigh religion in this matter. As an example look at Dubai. An Islamic state technically governed under Sharia, and yet prostitution is extremely prevalent. And I'm not talking about sex trafficking, but independent providers making a good living. Go to any nightclub and you'll have an exceedingly easy time walking out with a prostitute. Hell, they even shove flyers under your door advertising their services. How they get away with it in a place where the penalty for unwed sex is death, I have no idea, but they do.

And Christianity is not only Catholicism. In the US the Catholic Church is not the top dog, and most definitely not the most worrisome one either (unless you're a little boy, but that's another subject). So I think we are dealing with a situation where otherwise opposing groups are finding common ground for different reasons. And as I was alluding to with my earlier comment about emotions, I think many of those reasons do not derive from any logical basis.

I think it's an emotion that has been ingrained into the social consciousness for far too long now. Take my wife (seriously, please take her :-) ) for example. She's a liberal, wishy-washy Wiccan, raised by a pair of hippies. She's a feminist in the original sense (equality for all), very open sexually, "never be judgmental of others" attitude, etc. but when it comes to prostitution she discusses it as though the topic is infanticide. She can't articulate her revulsion to it, but she feels it. Just the other day we were discussing open relationships and she told me that she would like it if I had anonymous sex with other women as long as I don't fall in love with any of them. I mentioned prostitutes as a perfect solution, to which she replied "if you fucked a whore I'd cut off your dick with a rusted knife and then throw it into the garbage disposal." Why? What's the difference between a random stranger I met at a bar versus a prostitute? She couldn't say. She didn't even want to try to explain it. In her view I can fuck freely as long as it's not with a prostitute. She has no religious, political, or ideological motivation to this feeling, she's just grown up in a culture that doesn't tolerate it and she's never been willing to challenge her beliefs with logic.

Trust me, I'd also like to just blame it all on religion, but I think there's more to it than that.

My feeling is that you are right. It seems almost all contentious debates in this country become reduced to pure emotion, and slippery slopes are employed all the time. I tried posting about prostitution on another forum once, and the only argument against it that seemed to have any force was about human trafficking. The guy cited some alarming number in the Netherlands, and someone else from Germany chimed in that it's a big problem there. I wonder what it would take for this issue to be debated civilly and rationally, or if it's just an incurable tendency of our country to be hysterical when it comes to sex.

Most countries in the World with legal prostitution were/are majority Catholic  population.
  Sinning Catholics go to Church on Sunday, confess to priest,  sinner  is instantly absolved of his  sins  via the priest's direct line of mind linking with  God.  
  The priest is required by Papal law to never repeat the confessor's sin.  
 Sins stay between the three of them,  God, sinner, priest.
   
   The devout Catholic's status quo, sin all week ,confess  on Sunday,  free to sin again on fresh slate Monday.
   
   America with it's increasing population of sissy men with their added burden of no Religion and no way to communicate with God, most often find their guilt is too much to bear and confess their indiscretions to their GF or wife.
 99% of the time  she  will feel extreme contempt, scorn, and secret jealousy, when she finds her man has paid a Hooker for casual sex.  
   She is usually not forgiving like a Catholic priest and God.
   
  There are millions and millions of women in the U.S. with no allegiance to Religion yet they rally others to condemn prostitution.  
 I find it odd those same women believe a woman should be free to choose to do, almost anything with her own body, except make some extra money doing what most secure women  love to do, enjoy sex.

http://prostitution.procon.org/view.resource.php?resourceID=000772
   

Posted By: rainy_days
I've not really delved far into the issue, but it is my feeling that public opinion (in the US) is pretty strongly opposed to legalized prostitution. Of course the public follows wherever it is led, so I'm wondering, what are the institutions driving the belief that prostitution is degrading and evil?  
   
 First thing that comes to mind is the Church, but it seems to me this country is growing more and more secular, and yet the hatred of prostitution remains. Also it occurred to me that throughout European (and probably world) history, prostitution has flourished even while religion hovered near zenith of its power. I wonder why modern America is different.  
   
 The "gender wars" in this country is a mess I hate to step into, but I feel it is probably relevant to this issue. The demonization of the male and the supposed empowerment of women seems to encourage the idea that the explicit sale of sex is yet another form of male victimizing female.    
   
 Lastly I think that individuals selling sex cuts into the profit of big business. One of the greatest selling tools is exciting and then exploiting the sexual urge. Everywhere in advertising and media we are tantalized with the image of sex, and being barred from buying the thing itself, we can only spend on the products we are made to associate with it. To make people spend endlessly, they must be kept hungry and dissatisfied... thus sex loses its power as a selling tool if people are allowed to fulfill their urges.  
   
 Anyway those are my thoughts. I'm curious to hear what others think of this subject.

Thanks for the thoughts and the link. It hadn't occurred to me before that guilt and confession might play into national attitudes. I too find it odd how the women in this country, who supposedly believe in sexual freedom, should condemn prostitution so strongly. It's hard to make sense of the dissonance in people's values.

People come here fom all over the word seeking a better life, mainly in the form of an occupation. Prostitution being legal would not reinforce this concep

JohnMilton_Esq582 reads

The opposition to prostitution has evolved and the players who are opposed today are strange “bedfellows” indeed.  Like GaG, I'm not a fan of  religion (yes, I know, putting it mildly).  Common sense is a much better guide to human relations imo (I didn't choose my alias handle by coincidence,  lol).  For years the primary driver in opposition to prostitution were the bible thumpers.  But as you point out, the progressives, especially the women progressives are now in the forefront of fervent opposition to prostitution.  Some of the womens rights leaders are even calling EVERY woman in P4P a victim of us horrible men.  Take a look at the linked article, it provides insight into the current "feminist" thinking.

Based on where we are today and the fact that even some countries who previously legalized prostitution are now scaling back (being legal to offer but now illegal to buy), imho we are not going to see legalized or better yet simply decriminalized P4P anytime soon in the good old USA.  

BTW,  Quadseasonal's theory on why some of the Latin (and heavily Catholic) countries have no problem with P4P is very interesting.

Posted By: rainy_days
Thanks for the thoughts and the link. It hadn't occurred to me before that guilt and confession might play into national attitudes. I too find it odd how the women in this country, who supposedly believe in sexual freedom, should condemn prostitution so strongly. It's hard to make sense of the dissonance in people's values.
-- Modified on 4/2/2015 4:36:38 PM

From my perspective,  Most, definitely not all, definitely most women preaching against a woman's right to rent her body as she pleases,  are  usually, not always, usually the type of woman who could not make a decent living in the bedroom.  
  The link you provided was written by the woman in the photo and link below.

  http://www.vu.edu.au/contact-us/meagan-tyler
 
   When I think of prostitution I think of Smiling Happy Adult Hookers, not women who prefer to pose looking  grim, without a smile on camera.  
     
    If jealousy could be removed from the equation  there would be much less protesting against the World's oldest profession and more happiness everywhere.  :-

Man, this kind of stuff drives me up the wall:

"This relies on misunderstandings of radical politics, the concept of structural oppression and tired old debates about false consciousness."

"Similarly, when anyone practicing radical politics points out that free choice is a fairytale, and that all our actions are constrained within certain material conditions ... It just means we’re not all floating around in a cultural vacuum making decisions completely unaffected by structural issues like systemic economic inequality, racism and sexism."

So often when I read feminist's comments on whatever issue, there is a whole underlying metaphysical system that is considered beyond debate. It is very much like religious discussions, where certain premises (by no means agreed upon by all) are taken for granted, and all arguments proceed from them. In this case it is that women are denied agency due to their oppression by men. It's hard to have empirical discussions with people who inhabit their own reality.

Prostitution could be illegal just to keep liberalism alive in the U.S.

You liberally spew incomprehensible, brainless babble on these boards.  Thanks.

Register Now!