Today or 1964?  Either way, I'll go Mary Ann.  Love the short shorts.

Mary Ann was always hot. I liked Ginger but Mary Ann always got me going.   Anytime and anywhere. Came on after Dark Shadows growing up in the Midwest. I lusted after Maggie Evans on that show.

 
There was a scene in "10" where Julie Andrews was at her play rehearsal with a nice top, leather pants and boots. Schwing...

I really don't remember the characters.  But, to answer your generic question I will go with the girl next door anytime.  Much more intriguing.  Guess it's more of the unknown factor.

From that era one of the sexiest women was Tina Turner, a classic example of a HOTTTT woman in spite of her looks.

Never understood "Girl next door" concept? Same for GFE except as a mythological character, cause if GFE was desirable, well........then she'd still be in my life.

I much prefer a woman who is comfortable with her self, comfortable with her sexaulity and thoroughly enjoys having sex.

Deprived and Dubious

Now that would be a party!!