Tarkenton shouldn't be there.  I'd substitute one of the above names (probably Luckman) and change the order some.

while Terry B had a great team around him, I have to give him the edge over Fran Tarkenton, who was an ofer in Super Bowls-Bradshaw was 4 for 4 and had a better arm-FT had a nice completion % but rarely threw the deep ball-and CY, any interview with Slingin' Sammy was a hoot and had more beeps than a long Morse Code message-He was the most profane man i've ever encountered-Great player and a terrific punter too-

position into what it is today. He held all of the career passing records until Marino and Favre came along, and set the standard on how to manage a game. Unitas and Bart Starr were the two most cerebral quarterbacks of their time.

Elway? Are you shittin me?????

Where is Kenny Stabler? Bradshaw? Dan Fouts?

I'd take Tarkenton over Favre anyday and twice on tuesday.

Tom Brady? Yeah Right!!!!!!!!!

And i thought i drank too much. Where is Tasha to hold me at a moment like this?

My boy Joe made the cut though i see.

Hey mrfisher? Nice to see a controlled demeanor on the board.

-- Modified on 2/11/2010 12:57:55 PM

The case against Y.A is that he had more career interceptions than touchdowns and never won a championship.

THOSE ARE TOP 5,  ENOUGH SAID,